Point-Counterpoint: Hoco Heroes vs. Homecoming Court: Is the Change Worth It?

Yes – Jill Cooper:

Homecoming Court has been a longstanding tradition within most American schools, previously including Unionville. However, concerns with this system have given rise to a new way to celebrate students during the homecoming season: Homecoming Heroes. Ultimately, this new change is a positive one for the high school.

The competition for a spot on the Homecoming Court can spark resentment and issues between students. Intense campaigning, voting choices among students, and rejection for the losing candidates can leave students feeling hurt or betrayed. Additionally, many students may feel that the voting system for homecoming court favors popularity over character. Although the intention of Homecoming King and Queen is to honor students and add some fun to the starting school year, it can end up turning into the opposite. The replacement with Homecoming Heroes allows all the benefits of Homecoming Court without any of the negatives.

The title of ‘Homecoming Hero’ is given to students chosen for their exemplary school spirit, strong virtue, or positive attitude. It allows teachers to recognize students that they believe are ‘Heroes.’ This new title eliminates the competitive nature of Homecoming King or Queen, but it still keeps the tradition fun for the school. The title of Homecoming Hero also eliminates the designated genders that come with the titles of King and Queen, creating a more inclusive environment. Thus, replacing Homecoming King and Queen with Homecoming Heroes is an important change that allows every UHS student to feel included and valued.

No – Cayden Pinto:

This year at Unionville High School’s homecoming, instead of a homecoming court with a king and queen, a few students were recognized as “homecoming heroes” by teachers and other staff members. Although this change might not seem like a big deal, it is taking away the joy and excitement that comes from homecoming. There may be advantages of this new homecoming heroes system, such as reducing the aspect of popularity and giving students a fair chance; however, these get overshadowed by the disadvantages.

A traditional homecoming court makes for friendly competition which could increase school spirit. Also, the voting aspect of the homecoming court builds some excitement which adds to the whole excitement of the football game and the dance. Instead of being a popularity contest, the homecoming court allows students to foster connections, and celebrate their friends rather than teachers celebrating students. Not only that, many weren’t familiar with homecoming heroes. The announcement of it wasn’t as anticipated as a homecoming court reveal.

Getting rid of homecoming court means that memorable experiences are lost, and discourages school spirit. The homecoming heroes idea doesn’t have to go, but it would be best for the school if they kept the homecoming king and queen as well. A traditional homecoming court may be a little harder to organize, but it is definitely worth the extra effort.